DISCUSSION
Our first demonstration of photonic entanglement swapping between two independent and remote quantum emitters marks a major step toward the construction of quantum repeater networks with nonprobabilistic entangled-photon-pair sources. Within the broader vision of realizing the quantum network displayed in
Fig. 1B, future developments should pursue three key objectives: (i) boosting both the entanglement swapping fidelities and rates; (ii) interfacing the swapped photons with suitable quantum memories capable of storing and retrieving polarization qubits; and (iii) deploying the developed technology in urban quantum communication scenarios.
1) Even if the swapping fidelities are unambiguously above the classical limit, advanced quantum communication applications require a higher level of entanglement. As a benchmark, we take a yet-to-be demonstrated quantum key distribution (QKD) protocol with entanglement-swapped photons from remote QDs. To successfully share a secret key between remote network locations, we estimate that it is necessary to have an entanglement fidelity well above 80. This is higher than what we achieved here, but our theoretical and experimental work suggests the path for improvement: Considering the high entanglement of the initial photon pairs, the swapping fidelity is primarily limited by the accuracy of the BSM and, therefore, by the visibility of two-photon interference, as mentioned above. Our visibilities are now limited by the existence of energy-time entanglement (
55) as well as by the presence of residual charge noise (
24).
To alleviate this hurdle, one can engineer the ratio between the X and XX lifetimes (
55) either by designing photonic cavities with differential Purcell enhancement for X and XX (
58) or by using diode-like structures to control the electric field across the QD (
59). The first solution has recently been demonstrated on QDs in the same cavity architecture. With this approach, HOM visibility of 90% has been reached. The use of diode structures has demonstrated HOM visibilities as high as 80% without temporal postselection, a value that would allow pushing the swapping fidelity just above the threshold needed to successfully perform QKD. Furthermore, the integration of those diode structures onto CBR has recently been demonstrated, making this approach technologically accessible (
60,
61). The electric field can also be used to suppress residual charge noise, with demonstrated HOM visibilities as high as (
62), albeit in structures with negligible Purcell enhancement and without pumping the XX state for entangled photon generation. The electric field can also be instrumental to increase the overall swapping rates. As discussed in text S6, the presence of blinking in our CBR limits the fourfold coincidence rate by almost a factor of 80. However, recent results (
60) have demonstrated that blinking can be fully suppressed using electric fields. Therefore, we envisage that the use of diode-like structures in properly designed CBRs will be instrumental to boost the level of entanglement and minimize the number of attempts needed to successfully establish entanglement between remote network nodes. More specifically, in text S6, we estimate that state-of-the-art improvements of the source can push up to 0.17. This value, when using our experimental setup, would result in a coincidence rate close to 3 kHz, already above the value that can be achieved with probabilistic sources of entangled photons (
19).
2) Interfacing single and entangled photons from QDs with quantum memories is crucial for a functioning quantum network. Several systems can be used for this purpose, such as rare-earth–doped crystals, diamond color centers, and alkali-based quantum memories (
41). The latter have been used in recent demonstrations of on-demand storage and retrieval of single photons from QDs (
63), even in combination with CBR cavities (
64). Despite these advances, additional efforts are needed to improve memory efficiency and storage time and extend its operation to polarization-entangled photons. Modifications of the source are also needed as bandwidth matching is crucial to boost the overall protocol efficiency. The differential Purcell enhancement proposed above is particularly suited for this purpose as the (short) XX photons could be used for the BSM while the (long) X photons could be interfaced with alkali atoms. This type of memory is also interesting for setting a frequency standard across the network (see
Fig. 1B). In this case, it would also be necessary to erase the small differences in XX binding energies that we observe in dissimilar QDs (see
Fig. 2, B and C, and text S5.3), a task which can be accomplished using the combined effect of strain and electric field (
44). This would allow turning the swapping schemes of
Fig. 2 (D and E) into the universal one shown in
Fig. 1A. Last, we want to point out that recent progress on spins confined in GaAs QDs (
31) shows that quantum memories based on the same hardware shown here could become feasible, with one QD acting as an entangled-photon source and another as a memory.
3) The next step is the exploitation of our entangled photon sources in real-life quantum networks. Given the emission wavelength of our GaAs QDs, free-space quantum links are the ideal choice. Recent demonstrations of entanglement-based QKD (
65–
67) as well as quantum teleportation (
53) suggest that remote entanglement swapping in an urban communication scenario is within reach. Once the source is improved, satellite entanglement-based quantum communication (
68) is also a path to explore. That said, we point out that our results are also relevant for fiber-based quantum communication. Recent works have shown enormous progress in the performance of single (
69) and entangled-photon sources (
70) based on C-band QDs, and our results could be directly transferred to the telecommunication bands. Alternatively, it is also possible to use GaAs QDs in combination with frequency converters, as recently used to implement quantum teleportation (
71). Therefore, we envisage that our first demonstration of entanglement swapping between remote QDs will now open the path for the construction of large-scale quantum networks that exploit nonprobabilistic entanglement resources to distribute entanglement across distant parties (
68–
76).
Acknowledgments
We thank P. Mataloni for the fruitful discussions, A. Miriametro for the technical contribution, and K. Broccoletti for administrative support.
Funding:
This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation program under grant agreement no. 899814, Qurope project (R.T., F.B.B., K.D.J., A.R., and M.B.R.), and no. 871130, Ascent+ project (A.R.); from the QuantERA II program that has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation program under grant agreement no. 101017733 via the project QDE-QKD (R.T., A.L., F.B.B., S.H., T.H.-L., and A.R.); and from the European Union’s Horizon Europe research and innovation program under EPIQUE Project GA no. 101135288 (R.T., M.B., F.C., A.L., and M.B.R.). We also acknowledge support from MUR (Ministero dell’Università e della Ricerca) through the PNRR MUR project PE0000023-NQSTI (R.T., F.B.B., and M.B.R.) and the European Commission by project QUID (Quantum Italy Deployment) funded in the Digital Europe Programme under the grant agreement no. 101091408 (R.T., G.R., P.B., and F.B.B.). A.R. acknowledges support of the EU HE EIC Pathfinder challenges action under grant agreement no. 101115575 (Q-ONE), from the QuantERA program via the project MEEDGARD (FFG grant no. 906046), the Austrian Science Fund (FWF) (10.55776/COE1, FG5, PIN4389523) via the Research Group FG5 (10.55776/FG5), and the cluster of excellence Quantum Science Austria (quantA) (10.55776/COE1), as well as the Linz Institute of Technology (LIT), and the LIT Secure and Correct Systems Lab, supported by the State of Upper Austria. T.H.-L. acknowledges funding from the German Federal Ministry of Research, Technology and Space (BMFTR), through the project Qecs (FKZ: 13 N16272). This work is supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (German Research Foundation) through the transregional collaborative research center TRR142/3-2022 (231447078) (F.S. and K.D.J.) and the European Research Council starting grant (LiNQs, 101042672) (F.S. and K.D.J.). S.F.C.d.S. acknowledges São Paulo Research Foundation (FAPESP), Brazil, process no. 2024/08527-2 and 2024/21615-8 for financial support.
Author contributions:
M.B. and G.R. performed the experiment with the contribution of F.C., P.B., and A.L. under the supervision of M.B.R. and R.T. M.B.R. developed the data acquisition code with the help of F.S. and K.D.J. M.B., G.R., F.C., P.B., and M.B.R. analyzed the data. M.B. performed the theoretical analysis with the help of F.B.B. S.F.C.d.S. and A.R. designed and grew the QD sample. M.B.R., T.M.K., T.O., Q.B., B.S.D., and S.K. designed and processed the circular Bragg-Resonator under the supervision of R.T., A.R., T.H.-L., and S.H. S.S. processed the micromachined piezoelectric actuator. G.R. and R.T. wrote the paper with contributions from all the authors. R.T. conceived the experiment and coordinated the project.
Competing interests:
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Data, code, and materials availability:
All data and code needed to evaluate and reproduce the results in the paper are present in the paper and/or the Supplementary Materials. This study did not generate new materials.